Indian Art Experts on the Elevating Role of Art: For Empathy, Catharsis and Resistance

For many people, the world of art might seem a bit queer and unapproachable – intimidating, even. To help bridge this communication gap, Ajay and Swati Piramal have thrown open the doors of their private art collection in Mumbai. A self-proclaimed optimist, Ajay Piramal describes their joy for collecting art – “I try to look on the brighter side. I like calm and peace. I don’t like morose subjects where there is a lot of conflict or fighting between things; or colours which are really dull, like blacks and greys. So in some ways our collection reflects my thinking.”

krishen khanna
A Far Afternoon, Krishen Khanna

E B White had said, with reference to the role of the writer, that “he should tend to lift people up, not lower them down.” And this too seems to be the Piramals’ outlook on art. Through the visual experiences offered by their collection, they seek to create positive spaces for change. Here we share notes from an open lecture series organised by the Piramal Art Foundation, in continuation to their Kaleidoscope exhibition in Mumbai.

Voices of the subaltern

Critic Gaytri Sinha eloquently described brightly painted scenes that adorn a Buddhist chaitya hall in the opulent ITC Maurya Hotel. Painted by Krishen Khanna, the scenes are of a north-Indian dhabba – the irony of the setting making it amply evident that the artist “did not just want to make it look like a rich man’s hotel.”  This is just one example discussed that day that portrayed the urgent necessity felt by many artists to empathise with the downtrodden through their works.

krishen khanna at ITC Maurya
The Great Procession at ITC Maurya Hotel, Krishen Khanna (Source:

In fact, for Khanna, the dhabba as a setting remained a continuing fascination throughout his life, with his paintings portraying in detail the heavy clothes that drape the dhabba’s visitors and the tight architectural quarters that contain them. Surely, this empathy springs often from a place of personal struggle – for Khanna, the self-taught artist, was a man who struggled to make a living as an artist. For quite a while since he quit his well-paying bank job, he painted with canvases stretched on the back of his toilet door, described Sinha, while his wife earned a living as a teacher.

Metaphor for the personal

This subconscious projection of personal struggles into the realm of expression is poignantly clear when we understand the words of Elbert Hubbard that “art is not a thing – it is a way.” Perhaps one of the most moving stories of personal catharsis is of K Ramanujam – the gifted artist who had a mental disability that severely hindered his verbal ability and social relations. His paintings provide fertile material for psychoanalysis, as art historian Dr Ashrafi Bhagat described, for his loneliness often found reflection in the surreal and imaginary worlds that he portrayed. The power that he could not experience in his personal life – where people often mocked him – reflected in the form of alter egos in his work. For instance, in one particular painting he is portrayed as a god that is riding on a horse.

Rootedness and resistance

In this complex process of reclaiming the personal within the realm of the external is equally evident a struggle among Indian artists, of the 60’s in particular, to reclaim a sense of “Indianness” in a post-independence era – as a reaction to western hegemony and its flood of abstract images. While K K Hebbar had aptly remarked on the irony of “studying Indian traditions in a Victorian school”– as he was a student at J J School of Art – Dr Ashrafi Bhagat emphasized how the 1960’s indeed marked a “watershed in the growth of Indian art”.  Some of the notable reinterpretations of our traditional roots that emerged from this prolific phase were of artists like KCS Paniker, who was inspired by the Ajanta paintings; and Velu Vishwanathan who was moved by images of deities covered in red kumkum. However, Dr Bhagat added that, though we have turned towards our immediate context, our ‘colonial hangover’ still prevents us from placing tribal and folk art in the same league as fine art.

KCS Paniker
Words & Symbols, KCS Paniker, 1968

Altogether, the lecture series provided a window for students, novices and enthusiasts alike, into the empathetic role of art and its rootedness in tradition. In its earnest efforts to make knowledge on art accessible to all, the Piramal Art Foundation is opening up doors to the art world. To engage with various kinds of audiences, they keep their concepts and events deep yet devoid of verbal complexity, and organise frequent free talks, workshops and tours in Mumbai. Keep a track of their events here.


Cover Image Source : Piramal Art Foundation

Yatra Archives His Pictures Tell Your Story : a Heart to Heart talk with photographer Vivek Desai

If photographers today wish to cover an age-old festival popular in a remote village, all they need to do is google for details. Date, place, time, schedule, it’s all listed on the well-designed website. Camera bag and lens in order,… 37th Saptak Annual Music Festival peaks during the weekend!

Day 7 ends with audience saying ‘Wah Ustad’ The seventh day of the music festival featured three concerts namely a violin recital by Vidushi Kala Ramanathan, Gundecha brothers presented drupad music and a Santoor recital by Shri. Rahul Sharma accompanied by… Sleep Comes Like A Drug : Fab Fables #5

It was July. This time, the monsoon was heavy and the moisture-laden air had dampened everything. But for the streak of yellow light originating from the street lamp, the room was dark.   He got up again with his toe… પ્રાર્થના / prayer (અસત્યો માંહેથી પ્રભુ! પરમ સત્યે તું લઈ જા)

Prayer by Nahnalal અસત્યો માંહેથી પ્રભુ! પરમ સત્યે તું લ‍ઈ જા, ઊંડા અંધારેથી, પ્રભુ! પરમ તેજે તું લઈ જા; મહામૃત્યુમાંથી, અમૃત સમીપે નાથ લ‍ઈ જા. તું-હીણો હું છું તો, તુજ દરસનાં દાન દ‍ઈ જા. પિતા! પેલો આઘે, જગત વીંટાતો સાગર…